The Usefulness Of The Canadian Senate - 1687 Words

David C. Docherty’s scholarly journal responds to the continual controversy and debate of the usefulness of the Canadian senate in 2002. Docherty’s article does an amazing job at analyzing the current Canadian senate and argues that the senate is a failing Canadian institution because of two democratic deficiencies: the undemocratic nature of senator selection and the inability of senators to represent provinces properly (45). These two features of why the senate is a failing Canadian institution can be compared to how Rand Dyck defines democracy in Canadian Politics: Critical Approaches. Docherty looks at several previous senate reforms and answers the question of why these senate reforms failed, in doing so Docherty lays down a framework for a possible successful senate reform but acknowledges the obstacles. Docherty does a very good job at accessing the problem of the senate, accessing the problem of previous reforms, and suggesting a plausible type of reform for the senate. This provides the reader with the knowledge of why the Canadian senate is a failing institution but also the possible solutions of how the senate can be reformed in order to maximize its democratic potential. Although, Docherty fails to provide an exact reform that needs to be taken, he just draws upon other failures and hypothesis that this may be the right solution for reform. Rand Dyck’s chapter 11 fills in the missing gap of reform that needs to be taken by drawing upon one of the best attempts atShow MoreRelatedSenate Reform2136 Words   |  9 Pagescountry. Conversely, the upper house, the Senate, according to Section 24 of the Constitution Act (1867), states: â€Å"The Governor General shall†¦ summon qualified Persons to the Senate; and†¦ every Person so summoned shall become†¦ a Member of the Senate.†[1] This has amounted to almost 800 Canadians being appointed to the Senate since Confederation. However, as Canadians have grown to deman d transparency and reject government action without accountability, the Senate and its antidemocratic actions have allowedRead MorePolitical Parties Essay3091 Words   |  13 Pagesto an unwillingness to compromise, making for inflexible relations within the network, with potential supporters, and, it goes without saying, with the opposing party. The result is that the direction ideology ordinarily gives to a party and its usefulness in rallying support becomes a source of bitter conflict. Goal Direction An example of how candidate selection can affect a party’s goal direction is when an individual who has gained fame in some other capacity, like sports, then turns to runRead MoreMethods of Qualitative of Data Collection19658 Words   |  79 Pagesethnographic film for its obvious strengths. Visual samples enhance the value of any record. Film documents life crises and ceremonies, transmits cultural events to successive generations, and documents social conflicts (court proceedings, public speakers, Senate sessions, and so on). The film researcher is 04-Marshall-4864.qxd 2/1/2006 3:16 PM Page 121 Data Collection Methods 121 limited by what the mind can imagine and the camera can record— significant limitations because they involve ideology andRead MoreLogical Reasoning189930 Words   |  760 Pageswhat somebody says simply because they raise their voice, and narrowly thinking about a problem without bringing in the most relevant information. This first chapter explains what it means to be logical—to reason logically. It demonstrates the usefulness of logical reasoning as a means to making more effective decisions about your own life—decisions about what to believe and decisions about what to do. The chapter begins a systematic program of study of all the major topics regarding logical reasoningRead MoreProject on Risk Management46558 Words   |  187 Pagesbased on financial statements (capital adequacy ratios) can be misleading because some emerging market economies do not follow international accounting standards and accounts are not properly audited. Supervision and regulation can also affect the usefulness of financial statements In line with the preceding, Rojas-Suarez (2004) shows that the traditional measures of banking health most commonly used in industrial countries, such as the capital/asset ratio, have performed poorly as indicators of bankingRead More_x000C_Introduction to Statistics and Data Analysis355457 Words   |  1422 PagesWisconsin concluded that there was an association between iron deï ¬ ciency and the length of time that a child is bottle-fed (Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, November 26, 2005). Describe the sample and the population of interest for this study. 1.5 The st udent senate at a university with 15,000 students is interested in the proportion of students who favor a change in the grading system to allow for plus and minus grades (e.g., B , B, B , rather than just B). Two hundred students are interviewed to determine theirRead MoreMarketing and E-commerce Business65852 Words   |  264 PagesUniversity of Denver Tom Critzer, Miami University Dursan Delen, Oklahoma State University Abhijit Deshmukh, University of Massachusetts Brian L. Dos Santos, University of Louisville Robert Drevs, University of Notre Dame Akram El-Tannir, Hariri Canadian University, Lebanon Kimberly Furumo, University of Hawaii at Hilo Karen Palumbo, University of St. Francis Wayne Pauli, Dakota State University Jamie Pinchot, Thiel College Kai Pommerenke, University of California at Santa Cruz Barry QuinnRead MoreManaging Information Technology (7th Edition)239873 Words   |  960 Pagesserving as departmental computers, handling specific tasks such as Chapter 2 †¢ Computer Systems 31 The Smallest PCs: Smartphones Smartphones are here to stay, with the Apple iPhone and various BlackBerry devices (from Research in Motion, a Canadian company) leading the way. Smartphones combine the functions performed by conventional handheld PC, or personal digital assistants (PDAs), with the ability to make phone calls. These devices permit the user to make phone calls, pick up and send e-mail